Negative effects of age-based social media restrictions in new research
Nearly half (45%) of children say that age-based restrictions on social media would not make them feel any safer online, according to a new report comprising 19 European countries. Researcher say that restrictions may address some risks but this would be at the cost of important online opportunities. The report comes at a time when an increasing number of governments are announcing that they plan to follow the Australian initiative with age restrictions for social media access.
Evaluating the effect of restrictions after half a year, 7 in 10 Australian parents say teens aged 13 to 15 who were on the social media platforms before the ban were either never kicked off or managed to create new accounts, the New York Times reports referring to the Australian regulator in charge of implementing the law.
In the EU Kids Online survey of 29,169 children aged 9–16 across Europe, young people say social media bans could cause issues around freedom, responsibility, social connection, education, and democratic participation. The study is published by London School of Economics and Oslo University.
“The evidence shows that age bans will restrict the significant opportunities that children currently value to communicate, learn and relax. Recognising that these opportunities are too often accompanied by risks, it is time for digital services to be designed and regulated in ways that respect all of children’s rights”. Says professor Sonia Livingstone at London School of Economics.
The survey shows that young people either somewhat (19%) or strongly agree (26%) that an age ban would limit their freedom and rights. Many also feel it would take away their own responsibility to decide (47%).
“Age bans may appear to offer a simple and efficient solution, but they risk excluding children rather than addressing the design and governance failures that create online risks. Children need safer digital environments, not fewer opportunities to participate”, says professor Elisabeth Staksrud at University of Oslo.
“This is important in the wider age bans debate because restrictions are often framed as protective measures, but young people may experience them as a loss of agency rather than as support”, LSE says in a research summary.
The report found that while up to one in five 9–16-year-olds in Europe report encountering some forms of problematic user-generated content (with conspiracy theories being the most reported problematic content), children’s worries tend to be much broader, including family illness or death, war, future employment and school achievement.
“Children report using social media for a wide range of activities. Communication with friends is the most frequent activity, followed by watching videos on social media, listening to music and communicating with parents or caregivers.”
“Young people are also using the internet for education and information, with children from lower socio-economic homes more likely to search online for information about mental health and wellbeing.”
“While some children report exposure to risks online including potentially harmful content, image-based abuse concerns, pornography, eating-disorder content and misinformation, the findings show patterns of exposure, not simple causality”, LSE reports.
The researchers note the findings do not establish whether social media causes harm, whether vulnerable children are more likely to encounter or seek out certain content, or whether online and offline difficulties reinforce each other.
“Exposure does not automatically mean harm, and risks vary by age, gender, socioeconomic status, vulnerability, intention and platform context.”
The researchers argue that while age bans, if they can be effectively implemented, may address some risks for some younger children, the findings show that this would be at the cost of important online opportunities.
“A more balanced approach would combine age-appropriate protections, safety-by-design, platform accountability, digital literacy, support systems and attention to children’s rights to participation, information and social connection.”
Moonshot News is an independent European news website for all IT, Media and Advertising professionals, powered by women and with a focus on driving the narrative for diversity, inclusion and gender equality in the industry.
Our mission is to provide top and unbiased information for all professionals and to make sure that women get their fair share of voice in the news and in the spotlight!
We produce original content, news articles, a curated calendar of industry events and a database of women IT, Media and Advertising associations.
